Mechanic Vs. Dealer Pros and Cons

Everyone’s stomach drops when they turn on their car only to hear a strange, unpleasant noise coming from the engine. You know it will only get worse if you ignore it, so you decide to take it in for repairs and cross your fingers it doesn’t end up costing you a fortune. But what are you supposed to do if your warranty just ran out? Should you continue taking your car to the dealer or find an independent local mechanic? There are distinct pros and cons to each choice, and at the end of the day, it’s all about weighing which factors matter most to you and making an informed decision.

Dealer: Pros

If you have a luxury car and want to make sure it’s only repaired using the original manufacturer’s parts, the dealer is the way to go. They’ll be experts in your specific car brand, and their mechanics are required to exclusively use the original manufacturer’s parts for all repairs and replacements.

Mechanic: Pros

Dealing with a locally and independently-owned business means you’ll be building personal relationships with your mechanic and will get more personalized service, all while supporting your local economy. Most mechanics can work on a wide variety of different car brands, so you can take all your family cars into the same shop for repairs and inspections. One of the most significant advantages to going with an independent mechanic is that labor will be significantly cheaper, and you won’t be breaking the bank with every small repair. Local mechanics can also recommend alternative parts that are cheaper, whereas the dealership can only use original manufacturer parts. You can also find a mechanic that’s closer to your home and more convenient to get to. Aarrow Transmission is an auto service in Richmond, VA, that offers world-class auto repair and transmission service. Like most local mechanics, they’ve built their business on superior customer service and quality workmanship, so you can trust they’ll get the job done right every time.


Dealer: Cons

Once your warranty runs out, you’ll probably be paying a lot more for parts and labor at the dealership versus at a local mechanic. Since you’ll likely be dealing with a service advisor instead of dealing with the mechanic directly, you won’t be able to build a personal relationship with your mechanic, which might put you at risk for being pressured into repairs and services you might not need. Another downside of going with the dealer is that it’s unlikely that the dealership will be as close to your home as a local mechanic will be. Doing a simple search for “auto mechanic near me” will show you how many local mechanics there are within just a few miles of your home.

Mechanic: Cons

If original manufacturer parts are the most important thing to you, you might not want to go with a local mechanic. Also, if your car is still on warranty, you’ll probably need to get your repairs done at the dealer.